cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Smoking Cessation and Weight Gain in Women

Dr_Hays
Mayo Clinic
4 15 481

Nearly everyone gains weight after smoking cessation. Multiple scientific studies confirm the average is about 10-12 pounds of gain in the first 5-7 years after smoking cessation. Do women gain more weight than men? It turns out there is little average difference between the amount of weight gained by men and women (although men seem to care a lot less about weight gain).  The greatest driver of more weight gain after smoking cessation is baseline weight at the time you quit smoking and how heavily you smoked. Ex-smokers who were overweight or obese when the quit smoking gained more on average than those who were near or below their ideal body weight and heavier smokers tend to gain more weight than lighter smokers after smoking cessation. There are many other important differences between men and women that may influence weight gain after smoking cessation, and one of them is menopause experienced by women usually around age 50.

A 2017 study examined women enrolled in the Women’s Health Initiative that included over 90,000 post-menopausal women who were followed for many years to study factors that influenced their health.* When they looked at the impact of long-term smoking cessation on ultimate weight gain here is the bottom line—the women on average quit at age 41 and over 20 years later they weighed about 6 pounds more than the women who never smoked and about 10 pounds more than those who continued to smoke. Every group of the women in the study (never smokers, former smokers and current smokers) gained weight over their lifetime from age 18 to 65. Women who formerly smoked gained a total of 37 pounds, never smokers gained 36 pounds and continuing smokers gained 32 pounds. One way to look at this is that the women who continued to smoke throughout their adult lives traded over 45 years of smoking (and about 6-10 years of life lost!) for 5 less pounds of weight gain compared to the women who stopped smoking. No one would make that trade!

Healthy lifestyle including diet and exercise habits and maintaining healthy weight as we age is important for increasing length and quality of life. Smoking cessation will have greater impact on your future health than all other health habits you can change… even if it costs gaining a few pounds over a lifetime.

Dr. Hays

*Kabat GC, Moonseong H, Allison M, et al. Smoking habits and body weight over adult lifespan in postmenopausal women. Am J Preventive Med 2017;52(3):e77-e84.

15 Comments
Barbscloud
Member
PastTense
Member

I am 100% not interested in the averages of thousands (or millions) of other people.  This is just another excuse for the medical profession to dismiss my personal concerns about weight gain.  Just because somebody else gained more (or less), that has no meaning to ME.

There are those of us who care A LOT and who have worked very hard our entire lives to keep our weight under control.  Let the medical establishment speak to that and address my struggle  or frankly, just shut up.

This guy has obviously never been rendered invisible because of his weight.  Weight bias is real and it's blatant.  This kind of dismissal is infuriating.

Barbscloud
Member

@Dr_Hays  Thanks for providing more information on quitting smoking and weight gain.

I have to agree with @PastTense that some of us don't fall into the average range.  I'm sure the data is accurate, but that doesn't address those of us that fall outside the norm who are struggling with their weight gain after quitting smoking.  

 "The greatest driver of more weight gain after smoking cessation is baseline weight at the time you quit smoking and how heavily you smoked. Ex-smokers who were overweight or obese when the quit smoking gained more on average than those who were near or below their ideal body weight and heavier smokers tend to gain more weight than lighter smokers after smoking cessation." 

  I weighed 130 lbs. when I quit smoking.   I don't even want to say how much I weigh now because I am so devastated by the weight gain that I invested 45 years  in keeping if off after losing 100 lbs.   Is this much weight more beneficial than smoking?   I'm not convinced of that. 

I exercised when I smoked and when I quit.  Hasn't made any difference. 

Barb

Note:   long past menopause when I quit.

PastTense
Member

I guess the point I was making, @Barbscloud ; is that the medical establishment doesn't care about individuals.

They look at a study of 900K people and dismiss the individual because the "average" weight gain is less harmful than smoking.  They do not address any of the societal costs of gaining weight.  They do not address any of the emotional or psychological affects of gaining. 

They will do NOTHING about it except make those of us who gained more feel even worse.

They could, but they don't 

MikeBurke
Mayo Clinic

Hello PastTense,

I apologize for my tone deafness in citing the statistics.  We do strive to hear and work with each person as the individual they are and I should have heard you and others here in that light.  I can certainly hear how my relaying of the data may have replicated the hurt already inflicted by the medical establishment and do sincerely apologize

Mike Burke

Barbscloud
Member

@Dr_Hays  Thanks for responding to @PastTense  and just ignoring me.  I raised this issue years ago.  Maybe it's time for me to move on.  This site isn't providing the support I need any more.  Smoking looks real appealing to me right now.

Bye

Barb

Giulia
Member

@MikeBurke  Dr. Burke, I find it a little confusing when this blog is attributed to Dr. Hayes, but then you apologize for "tone deafness."  Which of you actually wrote the blog?  Do you all just write each other's material interchangeably at Mayo?  Some clarification on that might be helpful, or at least correct attribution or - something.  Just - my opinion.

MikeBurke
Mayo Clinic

I thought @PastTense was also referring to the blog i had written on the same topic recently. We each write our own blogs. I should have included Barb in the response.  Sorry for the confusion

Giulia
Member

Thanks for the explanation.  That helps.  I realize that sometimes there are ghost writing necessities and a lot of times others are writing for the doctors in their name, but when Dr. Hayes was blamed specifically and you apologized, I thought a clarification might be helpful.

PastTense
Member

So here we are; there are statistics that ex-smokers get fat but not one single idea on how to lose that fat.  Smoking changes your body and metabolism.  Quitting changes your body and metabolism.

What is the medical community doing to address (or at least research) the very specific needs of ex-smokers trying to lose weight?  Because reducing calories and increasing exercise does not work.

NDC_Team
Mayo Clinic

Hello PastTense,

Below is a link to a description of clinical trials looking at this important problem.  You can find by changing search terms (e.g. tobacco use to smoking cessation) that there are additional studies either ongoing or completed.  I know that this is not enough, or probably satisfying, but there is a lot of research that has been done, or is currently ongoing, to learn more about how to help with this difficult problem.

Research on tobacco and weight gain

PastTense
Member

Interesting, @NDC_Team .  Thank you for sharing this research.

According to these studies, there really is no help for us at all.  The best case I saw was gaining only 9lbs as opposed to 10 lbs in the control group.

That does not fill me with optimism.

Noodle5673
Member

Are you on any other medications? If you research any medication you are currently taking and “weight gain”, see if any of them show to cause it. A lot of sleeping medications cause you to gain weight, I was prescribed doxepin and when I quit I lost 50lb within 3 months. I had no idea how much it impacted my metabolism. Also there are studies that show if you close your eyes and imagine eating, your mind and body actually thinks it is more full than it is. And sucking on a lot of jolly ranchers to have something in your mouth is better than just eating every time you want something in your mouth since it’s more of being used to hand/mouth stimulation than the cigarette itself.

virgomama
Member

Data, by its nature, is objective or "tone deaf" as has been used here.  It's supposed to be.  A medical Dr.s job is to rely on science and data.  Psychologists deal with personal emotional issues.  This blog is simply a style of communication by a trained Dr. sharing facts.  I don't think any hurt or insult was intended here.

Gypsy15108
Member

No but sometimes speaking out helps make them look at a different reality.

About the Author
An expert in tobacco use and dependence, Dr. Hays has authored and co-authored over 70 peer-reviewed scholarly articles and book chapters on various aspects tobacco dependence and its treatment. Since joining the Nicotine Dependence Center in 1992, he and its staff have treated more than 50,000 patients for tobacco dependence.